Adwords display ads

12 January 2018

Should I use display networks?

Things don't always go right when using Google Display Networks - a warning from history.

One of the ways Google makes its money is by allowing you to advertise your company on the results page of a search. Your ad appears when a visitor types something that's relevant to you - cool, works for Google, works for you.

They also use a lesser known technique called Display Networks.

Display Networks allows website publishers (owners) to make money by displaying your Google ad on their website and raking off a proportion of the income - your money if you advertise on Google. If you don't manage where your ads appear then Google will do it for you.

In Search advertising there is a relationship between the search terms or keywords you chose to display your ad - essentially the more you bid, the higher up your ad appears. Google employs a clever formula called a Quality Score which compares your keywords to your landing page to ensure that, even though you are paying a decent bid rate, they would mark you down if the keywords you used were not relevant to your website.

In Display Networks this is not the case.

In an unmanaged campaign, your ad can appear just about anywhere - specifically on websites that have absolutely nothing to do with your product or service. Worse, you have no control over the number of clicks that are made on your ad.

A few years ago, a customer of mine set up a campaign to market services on a very niche mobile phone. He set it up using both conventional Google Search as well as Display Advertising. The end result of the campaign was a real shock.

  • Over the whole period of the campaign - around 6 months - he had 38 clicks on the search side and...wait for it....9,153 on the Display Networks!
  • He had 2,121 Impressions (the number of times the ad was shown) on normal search and over 2 million on the Display Networks.
  • The clicks all came from completely unrelated sites and apps. "Candy Burst" and "Sudoku Free" by Tomato Game Studio were the top two with this company accounting for £1,045 of the costs.
  • Apps for camera editors, torches, art for kids running mainly on apps on Google Play and iTunes were responsible for the other half.
  • The customer spent £14.15 on the search campaign and over £2,000 on Display Networks.
  • He received no sales or conversions from the entire campaign.
  • Finally, and most suspicious of all, the campaign to clear his Adwords account lasted six weeks - there were no strange figures either before or after this date.

My client lost over £2,000 on a campaign which made him no sales and, worse, made criminals a lot of money for nothing; just clicking on ads.

Google refused to refund the loss.

I advise everyone who is considering using Google Ads and, specifically Display Networks, to:

  • Set a sensible daily budget
  • Set a campaign stop date every month.
  • Review a campaign regularly - hourly and daily if it's a biggy, weekly if not - base the interval on the amount of money you are prepared to lose through inaction.
  • Think hard about using Display Networks, they require serious thought and management
  • If you decide to include it in your marketing portfolio, do not let Google manage it - you decide where your ads are shown
  • Suspend your Display Networks advertising unless you are confident it hasn't been 'hacked'.

Although Google has developed a number of good anti-click fraud systems, as well as manual checks, the are not infallible and the fact that they refuse to investigate claims of malpractice reported to them more than 60 days after the theft is discovered means that the onus is on the advertiser to check the legitimacy of the campaign. You need to tell Google straight away if you are at all suspicious and they may give you your stolen money back.

Finally, and this is important, Google Ads is a great way of advertising your business, but it is my belief that there is substantial criminal fraud occurring throughout the Display Networks system. I am no detective but the small amount of evidence I have seen indicates that this is a very serious problem for Google's customers.

The real issue here is that there is a conflict of interest. Google benefits hugely from this fraud; their customers' money is shared between the fraudsters and Google and, with some estimates putting the fraud as being responsible for up to 30% of campaign spend, the amount of money runs into billions of dollars.

I will go far as saying that Google's Display Network should be formally investigated in any country in which they operate. Relying on the company itself to reduce an activity which it patently benefits from is nonsensical.

My advice: be very careful using Display Networks full stop. I am recommending that all my customers stop using this form of advertising until Google cleans up its act.

Hywel Thomas web designer

Author: Hywel Thomas
Web Design and Google Ads person
Email: hi@zigger.co.uk

ReviewsContact Us

Reviews

All Google ReviewsAll FreeIndex Reviews
Google review

A fantastic experience of working with Zigger to develop my website. Hywel is extremely meticulous with his approach and developed a tailor-made website that fulfilled my challenging requirements extremely well, and is always very rapid to sort out any troubleshooting met along the way. A thoroughly positive experience, have no hesitation to recommend!
Jaymee Coonjobeeharry, Surrey

Freeindex review

Very responsive, completely understood my requirements and made many helpful suggestions. Hywel is a complete professional who understands how to get the most out of the web. A delight to work with.
Chris Pearce, Walton on Thames

Google review

I couldn't recommend Zigger enough, it's been a stress free experience from start to finish. I had so much support and felt in very capable hands - thank you!
Nicole Brannan, Esher

Google review

I have worked with Zigger on a number of projects over the past few years, they are always a pleasure to work with and produce fantastic results. I have recommended their services to others and would not hesitate to do so in the future.
Gary Carter, Leatherhead

Google review

Zigger did a great website for my new company and helped me out on many aspects of SEO, email and Adwords. Highly recommended.
J Flock, Cobham

Google review

Zigger has been wonderful at setting up a website for us, and teaching us how to manage and update it to meet our evolving needs. Hywel has always shown extreme patience as we learned how to translate our ideas into a website format. No question is too simple, nor request too difficult and we've never had a delay when there has been a need to implement any updates. We would highly recommend Zigger for creating a website, as I think you'd be hard pressed to find a more personal responsive equivalent out there.
Monique Flynn, Chobham

Google review

It was a great pleasure working with Hywel from Zigger to design and create my Website. He incorporated all my own designs and listened to my views of how I wanted the Website to look and feel, before it all went live.
Lacky Sangha, Weybridge

Freeindex review

I needed a website for my business and tried a few people with no joy…then I found Zigger. Hywel explained everything clearly with no jargon or sales pitch. I sent the photos and text ideas and hey presto two weeks later a live site that was easy to use and looked a million dollars. If you want a website just use Zigger you won't regret it.
Dave Eyles, Southampton

Hywel created two beautifully designed websites for us. He was very helpful when it came to us taking over running them, coming to our offices to show us how to use the web designer program. Since handing the websites to us, he has always been at the other end of the phone to help us with any queries with doing things on the websites, and also providing on-going support with our online marketing. I feel that he went over and above the original remit in order to provide us with a bespoke service, and I would highly recommend his services to anyone looking for a friendly and helpful web designer.
Sue Spencer, Horsham

Google review

Zigger have done a fantastic job with our rather outdated website, gave it a fresh new look, whilst still maintaining the corporate identity. All done very quickly and professionally. Couldn't ask for a better service, and all at a competitive price.
Caroline Smith, Bookham

Google review

I'm very happy with Zigger and the website they produced for our deli. As well as building a great website for the business Hywel was able to advise on the marketing and content side of things, which was a great help and saved me a lot of precious time. Great job, just what we needed.
Matt Arlidge, Stoke D'Abernon

Google review

This was a very simple, easy and friendly experience. Hywel delivers exactly the service he says on the tin. No hassle, just built the website for me and managed it. good communication. I'd use him again.
Will Dennis, Cobham

Google review

I'm very happy with Zigger and the website they produced for our deli. As well as building a great website for the business Hywel was able to advise on the marketing and content side of things, which was a great help and saved me a lot of precious time. Great job, just what we needed.
Matt Arlidge, Stoke D'Abernon

Freeindex review

Hywel is a very approachable chap and explains things clearly. My final site looks "the business"and its great that I can now update content myself... And if I can't Hywel is available to help. Good job!
Andrew D. Brewis, Walton-on-Thames

Google review

Hywel is someone who doesn’t come along every day, he loves his work and really knows his stuff when it comes to website design. Really affable has loads of patience which was most definitely a requirement dealing with us! He also really helped with SEO advice, marketing and general advice to help us run the website efficiently and effectively. We have recommended Hywel and will continue to do so, a really hands on firm is Zigger and we really hope it gets Bigger, coz he deserves it! Thanks.
Clive Bennett, Claygate

As a graphic and digital designer, I can safely say working with Hywel has been a pleasure. Not only does he understand good design and user experience, but he also offers bespoke advice and guidance for your website to ensure it works to its full potential - no matter the industry in which it sits. I have worked with him on four websites now, and all have been a roaring success thanks to his patience, eye for detail and knowledge. Hywel is the only web developer I recommend to my design clients!
Daniel Bennett, Wimbledon

Freeindex review

Hywel has been involved with our company for many years and been responsible for our web site design layout and implementation. He has always been on hand to update/refresh our site and let us know of new systems and site best practice for optimum response. Any issues have been responded to quickly and costs have been very reasonable for the time involved. I can highly recommend Hywel for all web site design and ongoing support.
Kent McMillan, Molesey

Hi, how can we help?

You can call us anytime on:

0330 223 0078

07875 096483

hi@zigger.co.uk